Its best explained by this thread: https://mstdn.jp/@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social/117645039420648634
TL:DR is that Google’s business side is threatening to revoke android licenses from phones that support GOS and is likely planning to lock the bootloaders on Pixel phones going forward. Important to note is that in GOS own words, the actual Google Android team is seemingly not down with it and has helped GOS work on things like Vanadium. As it stands it seems like Graphene is trying to take legal action against Google.
Edit: apparently they’re also on track to start making new Android feature updates exclusive to the Pixel line of phones. We’re really in for a major shakeup in the phone market it seems.


You’re less secure and private in your communications using a dumb phone. Mms and cell calling are subject to the lawful intercept backdoor (which was famously found to be exploited at the hardware level a few years ago).
You’re better off with some ott encrypted messaging and voice over data.
Not true whatsoever if you actually just use it for what it’s meant for: emergencies, appointments etc. A more secure smartphone is worse because you’re creating a data gold mine on it even if it’s harder to get into. If your phone is purely for emergencies and appointments then there won’t be much data to grab. It’s very unlikely a conversation can’t be put on hold until you’re at home with your laptop/computer. Phones will always be the weakest link so long as people use them for messaging and whatever else beyond emergency contact. Because phones can be seized at checkpoints as well it opens up a world of hell that would just not be there if the phone was not actually used for anything important / had nothing on it.
I picked up a dumb phone from Amazon for $60 and have been using it as my daily driver. It might not be anymore private, but I would argue that it keeps me off the phone compared to a smart phone, and I can actually swap the battery and expand the memory if I want. Otherwise literally does the bare minimum when I am out, which is really what I wanted so I could kick smart phone addiction.
I’ve looked at Linux phones, but they are so expensive. I would rather just carry a Linux laptop around instead. Smartphones overall have lost their appeal for me. I’m really trying to go back to when I did not rely on them and the internet was something I visited at the computer in my house, rather than something I carried around with me at all times.
I’m really enjoying the dumb phone life.
I’ve been yearning for a return to
monkeepre-smart phone life. Screen addiction is out of control. I’ve Been wanting a dumb phone for like a year now so hearing someone else say they’re doing the same is encouraging.AGM M9 is what I am using. It’s T9 which really helps keep me from texting all day
Yeah. This is the only reason I haven’t switched to a dumb phone. Privacy/security is a necessity for anyone engaged in community organizing ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Most likely if they go back to a dumb phone their usage will be radically different, probably the bare minimum for which they might not care about encryption or hacking… as there will close to no interesting data.
That has not been my experience when friends and family have gotten dumb phones.
^ this.
My flip dumbphone has Android 8.1 on it - VoIP, Signal, XMPP etc are all possible. I suppose that makes it a dumb smartphone instead of a Nokia 3310. Though if the 3G shutdown had gone ahead, I’d be rocking my N95
Anyhow, I use my phone for calls, and SMS for trivial things.
For important stuff, there are other channels. Hell, I host my own non-fed 24/7 XMPP server with failover that can only be reached via Wireguard whitelist. It has OMEMO, Fail2Ban and Anubis on it.
Digital convergence was great…until it wasn’t.
Btw, worth noting there are now encrypted SMS and MMS apps. Yes, you have to convince the other person to install the app…at which point you’re better off using Signal or something else.
Be aware that there isn’t an Android 8.1 device that can’t be physically bypassed with off the shelf cop tools like cellebrite.
I don’t know how true that is as a sweeping statement about 8.1 but I don’t keep anything sensitive on my flip phone.
If we’re at the point where we need to use encrypted comms, I’d suggest not using any phone at all. Use something ephemeral like face to face or use something properly encrypted.
Anything you transmit via radio can be captured, decoded and used against you. If you’re swimming in those waters, Android 8.1 is the least of your worries.