• 2 Posts
  • 169 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 23rd, 2023

help-circle




  • It would be like KFC saying you can’t try to figure out how we made this food by eating it and taking the food apart and tasting it and testing it. And, again in my opinion, contract law (i.e., the terms of use for using the models) also does not provide the companies a viable claim because of a weird section of copyright law that basically doesn’t allow state law claims, such as contract claims, to be brought when they are in effect basically copyright claims.

    This is what most people don’t understand. Looking at a picture or looking at a web page is not stealing. Also, you can’t compress the entirety of “the internet” into a 20-200GB model. The claim that the data they store are even close to exact representations is bunk.

    Oh, you’re using this argument to claim that models shouldn’t be considered confidential and “trade secrets”. Well, yeah, but also that argument can be turned the other way. Fair use still stands.

    And I know you’re an IP attorney and all, but I would be okay if LLMs end up destroying the entire framework of copyright. It is a system created by the rich, to be only abused by the rich. We’re already seeing it slowly get dismantled first-hand with all of these decompiling experiments, and I’m sure that will be followed up with rich megacorps doing what they do best: playing the hypocrite by claiming one thing is infringing in their copyright, while what they do is totally legal.





  • The entire point of the study was to see what kind of context files were useful and which were useless,

    The title of the Pivot-to-AI article is: “Your AGENTS.md file doesn’t actually do anything”

    These two statements don’t jive.

    So when you say that they “admitted that they started with useless context files”, you are referring to the results of the study. Complaining that they didn’t base their study on the conclusions of that very study is just absurd

    This is the difference between “we found a lot of useless AGENTS.md files” and “AGENTS.md files cannot possibly be useful at all”. The second is the argument the article is making. The first is the argument the research paper is making, which like most things on the Internet, is effectively a tautology. Most of the internet is useless, and most people are too criminally stupid to even operate a computer.


  • Bad research is still bad. The main paper is 9 pages with wide margins, outside of references. This was a few college students publishing their CS research assignment. The “Limitations” section is rather telling:

    Another interesting avenue opened by this work is how to improve the automatic generation of useful context files.

    Okay, so they already admitted that they started with useless context files, which sabotages their own test.

    You know how you fix useless context files? You iterate until they are useful context files!

    This whole research paper is XKCD 385, except with AGENTS.md files.



  • This is a load of shit. AGENTS.md is just a rules file for a repo like anything else. Properly-written rules files give good direction into how to interact with a project. If you don’t think it’s being read, ask the agent, and figure out why.

    Far too many of these LLM articles are:

    1. I did the thing
    2. The thing didn’t work for me
    3. Pretend it’s a hyper-scientific experiment and write an article about it
    4. Declare X is shit because my version of X is shit, or because most people don’t know how to make X.

    You don’t do the thing and pretend the first draft is going to work perfectly. You iterate, ask the agent directly why it didn’t work or what kind of improvements could be made, and improve the process.

    Most of the time when I’m running through a repetitive process with a skill, I ask, “hey, what pitfalls did we learn from this process and how can we improve this skill?” Boom, iteration.

    Also, Pivot-to-AI is just some guy’s anti-AI blog site. He does the same shit on YouTube.









  • Rule #4: Don’t submit low-quality posts.

    Also, this user is a bot. Look at the post history. No normal user posts 40 entries in a 24 hour period. And no, I don’t mean they post a bunch of posts in one period, and bunch the rest in another period. I mean they are consistently posting 2-3 entries an hour without sleep, without a break.

    EDIT: Holy shit… 1.69K posts in two months.

    Yep, there it is. There’s the hook. This bot moderates exactly one forum as the only moderator, to sell a bunch of PC parts. There’s the scam. This is just like those YouTuber bots that link to a personal profile for a porn website.