He/Him Jack of all trades, master of none

  • 0 Posts
  • 222 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 10th, 2023

help-circle
  • The real question involves a perfect predictor, and asks whether it’s even possible to intend to only take one box. After all, when you get to that table, the money is already in the boxes. You necessarily will get either the same amount or more money by taking both, so there is no logical argument against taking both boxes.

    It’s definitely a hypothetical problem that can’t really exist, but to say that that makes it nonsense seems myopic to me. Plenty of unrealistic hypothetical problems are worth thinking about.



  • Their machine should be able to predict how dumb and irrational I am. Even if there is necessarily no downside to taking both boxes, I only take the mystery box.

    If I end up taking both boxes, then the machine may or may not have predicted that. But if I end up only taking the mystery box, then I doubt the machine would have predicted that I’d take both. I’m walking away with that cool mil