Carnism is not a made up slur. It refers to people who think that the commodification of animals, their bodies, and the products that can come from them, is morally acceptable. Its an unexamined, default ideology in all but a few cultures.
Don’t you think that a word made up in 2001 in order to shame non vegans is a little loaded? There are plenty of other words that fill the same niche. Human exceptionalism I think is a much better and wider descriptor, including exploiting plants, animals and minerals
Human exceptionalism is an adjacent term, but doesn’t encapsulate the vegan stance against the commodification of living beings, who choose to avoid suffering.
Both are alive, but plants are not sentient, they do not have central nervous systems, feel emotions or pain, or work to avoid suffering like sentient life.
Any child can tell you that there’s a fundamental difference between say, hitting a dog, and tearing a leaf, but carnists have tried to make the two actions seem morally equivalent.
Think of it like a bigot complaining about someone using the word bigot.
Speciesist’s complaining about being called carnists doesn’t really matter because its an accurate depicter that only the offender is complaining about.
This was my thinking too. A man who grows up in a patriarchal society, and agreeing with that ideology in a default, unexamined way, would probably equally reject the term misogynist after he heard it, despite that accurately describing what he is.
Carnists, hearing that term for the first time, also tend to reject it as a “slur”, despite it being an accurate term for what they are.
Don’t forget that you asked a question and everything I’ve said, whether you like what I said or not, has been in good faith. Including my response to you as OP.
Carnism is not a made up slur. It refers to people who think that the commodification of animals, their bodies, and the products that can come from them, is morally acceptable. Its an unexamined, default ideology in all but a few cultures.
Don’t you think that a word made up in 2001 in order to shame non vegans is a little loaded? There are plenty of other words that fill the same niche. Human exceptionalism I think is a much better and wider descriptor, including exploiting plants, animals and minerals
Human exceptionalism is an adjacent term, but doesn’t encapsulate the vegan stance against the commodification of living beings, who choose to avoid suffering.
Plants are living beings, what distinction are you going for?
Both are alive, but plants are not sentient, they do not have central nervous systems, feel emotions or pain, or work to avoid suffering like sentient life.
Any child can tell you that there’s a fundamental difference between say, hitting a dog, and tearing a leaf, but carnists have tried to make the two actions seem morally equivalent.
First time arguing with one?
It’s a fool’s errand
In my culture, vegetarianism and moral signalling on it are generally linked to casteism and discrimination based on caste.
I do see the POV behind veganism, but I am generally wary of that aspect.
Yes, I’m aware of the history of the word
And it is used as a slur, and you just used it as one
Jesus christ grow up
Think of it like a bigot complaining about someone using the word bigot. Speciesist’s complaining about being called carnists doesn’t really matter because its an accurate depicter that only the offender is complaining about.
This was my thinking too. A man who grows up in a patriarchal society, and agreeing with that ideology in a default, unexamined way, would probably equally reject the term misogynist after he heard it, despite that accurately describing what he is.
Carnists, hearing that term for the first time, also tend to reject it as a “slur”, despite it being an accurate term for what they are.
Removed by mod
Yes… Vegans are the assholes, and are the ones that think they are superior to other beings… 😐
Still not coinciding in good faith either.
Don’t forget that you asked a question and everything I’ve said, whether you like what I said or not, has been in good faith. Including my response to you as OP.